Math Class Didn’t Show Its Work, companion reader · Chapter 15

A Graph Is a Story

A graph reports two quantities at once, and its labels, domain and scale are part of the story.

These four demonstrations use the chapter's own rules and points. Move one input, read the point it makes, and check the coordinates with the rule before trusting the picture.

Every example in these readers is a constructed teaching example taken from or modeled on the book's own worked examples. The numbers are declared inputs chosen to make the mathematics visible. They are not measurements of any real person, product or study.

Demonstration 1 of 4

Between the tick marks

Does the graph of d(t) = 12 - 3t include inputs that fall between the tick marks?

When every real t from 0 to 4 is allowed, the rule gives an output at each one, so the points join into a line. When only whole numbers are allowed, the graph is five separate points.

\[d(t)=12-3t\]

\[12-3(0.5)=10.5\]

t is the input, in time units. d(t) is the output, in depth units. The domain is the set of allowed inputs, and it decides whether the points join into a line.

Predict first. Switch to whole-number inputs only. What happens to the point at t = 0.5?

Choose an example

Figure: Between the tick marks. Points at t = 0 to 4 with outputs 12, 9, 6, 3, 0, joined by a line. The input 0.5 is marked at output 10.5.
Allowed inputs: Every real t from 0 to 4, Input t: 0.5
Constructed example: the chapter's rule d(t) = 12 - 3t, with a count-domain contrast.

Calculated values

Domain
every real t from 0 to 4
Input t
0.5
Output d(t)
12 - 3(0.5) = 10.5

d(0.5) = 12 - 3(0.5) = 12 - 1.5 = 10.5, so the point (0.5, 10.5) belongs to the graph. The domain allows every real t from 0 to 4, so the line between the tick marks is part of the story.

Use the idea

Before connecting dots on any graph, ask whether the inputs between them are allowed. Counts of tickets or people usually are not.

Where the conclusion applies

The chapter declares every real t from 0 through 4. The whole-number version is the same rule given a count domain, like the chapter's ticket model.

Check your understanding: In the interval domain, what output goes with t = 3.5?
12 - 3(3.5) = 12 - 10.5 = 1.5, so the point (3.5, 1.5) is on the graph.

Chapter 15 source: section "A line includes inputs between the tick marks". Demonstration C15-D01.

Demonstration 2 of 4

Slope from two points

From (-2, 5) to (2, -3), how fast does the output change, and does the order matter?

The dashed legs show the horizontal and vertical changes between the two points. Reversing both changes flips both signs, so the fraction is unchanged. Reversing one flips only one sign.

\[-8/4=-2\]

\[(5-(-3))/(-2-2)=8/(-4)=-2\]

Slope is vertical change divided by horizontal change. Both changes must go from the same start point to the same end point.

Predict first. Reverse only the denominator's order. Will the slope still be -2, or will its sign flip?

Choose an example

Figure: Slope from two points. The points (-2, 5) and (2, -3) on a grid, joined by the falling line y = -2x + 1, with arrows for the horizontal and vertical changes in the chosen order.
Order of subtraction: First to second, Second point: (2, -3)
Constructed example: the chapter's points (-2, 5) and (2, -3), plus a vertical pair.

Calculated values

Order
first to second, both changes
Vertical change
-3 - 5 = -8
Horizontal change
2 - (-2) = 4
Slope
-2

Vertical change -3 - 5 = -8; horizontal change 2 - (-2) = 4. Slope = -8/4 = -2. The output falls two units for each positive input unit, whichever point you start from.

Use the idea

Write both changes with the same start and end labels before dividing. A sign that disagrees with the picture of a falling line is a warning.

Where the conclusion applies

The axes increase to the right and upward. If both points share the same horizontal value, the line is vertical and its slope is undefined, not zero.

Check your understanding: What is the slope from (0, 1) to (2, -3)?
Vertical change -3 - 1 = -4; horizontal change 2 - 0 = 2. Slope = -4/2 = -2.

Chapter 15 source: section "Worked example: a negative slope from two coordinates". Demonstration C15-D02.

Demonstration 3 of 4

Intercepts and the domain

The line y = 2x + 3 crosses the x-axis at (-3/2, 0). Does that point mean anything in the plan?

Both intercepts belong to the full line. The shaded band is the plan's domain; only the solid part of the line describes the plan.

\[0 = 2x + 3\]

\[x = -3/2\]

An intercept is where a graph meets an axis. Set x = 0 to find the y-intercept and y = 0 to find the x-intercept. The plan domain is 0 ≤ x ≤ 6.

Predict first. Switch to rule B, y = x + 7. Is its x-intercept inside the plan domain?

Choose an example

Figure: Intercepts and the domain. The line y = 2x + 3 with y-intercept (0, 3) and x-intercept (-3/2, 0), drawn solid only for inputs 0 to 6.
Rule: A: y = 2x + 3, Domain: Plan inputs 0 to 6
Constructed example: the chapter's example plan rules A and B.

Calculated values

Rule
y = 2x + 3
y-intercept
x = 0 gives y = 3: (0, 3)
x-intercept
0 = 2x + 3 gives x = -3/2: (-3/2, 0)
x-intercept in the model?
no, its input is negative

For y = 2x + 3: setting x = 0 gives y = 2(0) + 3 = 3. Setting y = 0: 0 = 2x + 3, so -3 = 2x and x = -3/2. The plan allows only 0 ≤ x ≤ 6, so (-3/2, 0) is an intercept of the line but has no meaning inside the plan.

Use the idea

When a model is used only for some inputs, check whether a calculated intercept lies among them before giving it a meaning.

Where the conclusion applies

The plans are invented. The algebra holds for every real x; the plan domain is a choice about which inputs the story covers.

Check your understanding: For y = x + 7, what is the y-intercept, and is it inside the plan domain?
x = 0 gives y = 0 + 7 = 7, so (0, 7). Its input 0 is inside 0 ≤ x ≤ 6.

Chapter 15 source: section "Intercepts need a domain". Demonstration C15-D03.

Demonstration 4 of 4

Where the lines cross

What does it mean that A and B cross at (4, 11)?

At each input, the two dots are the two outputs. They meet only at x = 4, where both rules give 11. Left of 4, B is higher; right of 4, A is higher.

\[A(x) = B(x)\]

\[2x + 3 = x + 7\]

A(x) = 2x + 3 and B(x) = x + 7 are the two example rules, for inputs from 0 through 6. The dotted line marks the chosen input.

Predict first. At x = 6, which rule gives the larger output, and by how much?

Choose an example

Figure: Where the lines cross. Two rising lines over inputs 0 to 6: A from (0, 3) to (6, 15) and B from (0, 7) to (6, 13), crossing at (4, 11). At x = 4, A is 11 and B is 11.
Input x: 4
Constructed example: the chapter's rules A(x) = 2x + 3 and B(x) = x + 7 and their table.

Calculated values

Input x
4
A(x)
2(4) + 3 = 11
B(x)
4 + 7 = 11
Larger output
tie: equal outputs

At x = 4: A(4) = 2(4) + 3 = 11 and B(4) = 4 + 7 = 11. The outputs are equal, so (4, 11) is the intersection. Solving 2x + 3 = x + 7 gives the same x = 4.

Use the idea

To check a crossing you read from a graph, put its input into both rules. Equal outputs confirm it; the graph alone is only an estimate.

Where the conclusion applies

The rules are invented and say nothing about which output is better. Solving 2x + 3 = x + 7 accounts for every real input, not only the four shown.

Check your understanding: At x = 2, what are A(2) and B(2)?
A(2) = 2(2) + 3 = 7 and B(2) = 2 + 7 = 9, so B is larger by 2.

Chapter 15 source: section "An intersection means equal output". Demonstration C15-D04.